Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf delivers a nationally televised address on Jan. 2, 2008.
"Musharraf Cannot Escape All Blame"
Op-Ed, The Australian
December 31, 2007
Author: Hassan Abbas, Former Senior Advisor, Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs
This op-ed also appeared in Zaman (Turkey) on December 29, 2007; Taipei Times (Taiwan) on December 31, 2007; and The Sunday Times (Sri Lanka) on December 31, 2007.
BENAZIR Bhutto's assassination is a serious blow to Pakistan's prospects for democracy and, indeed, its viability as a state. As chaos and confusion set in, we should not lose sight of Pervez Musharraf's partial responsibility. At the very least, he cannot be absolved from the Government's failure to provide Bhutto with adequate security.
Instead, Bhutto had to pay with her life for courageously challenging extremists of all stripes, from al-Qa'ida and Taliban to the country's religious political parties and military hardliners.
As heir to Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, the legendary democratic leader who was hanged by General Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq's government in 1979, Bhutto emerged as a symbol of resistance at a young age, but languished in jails and exile in the 1980s.
Her father's legacy was empowerment of the impoverished and defence of ordinary people's rights amid feudalistic politics and military rule. Rather than bowing to the military junta, he embraced the gallows.
Hours before his hanging, Bhutto was allowed to see her father for the last time. She later wrote in her autobiography: "I told him on my oath in his death cell, I would carry on his work." She largely lived up to the promise.
Her first stint as prime minister (1988–90) was brief and disorganised. General Hamid Gul, the former Inter-Services Intelligence chief, confirmed that he sponsored an alliance of right-wing political parties to stop her from getting a parliamentary majority. Information about Pakistan's nuclear program and ISI operations in Afghanistan were out of her domain.
Her second term in office (1993–96) was longer and better, but the government again fell early, owing to charges of mismanagement and corruption. In reality, machinations by the intelligence agencies also played a part. The military had developed an entrenched distrust of her, given her position as a popularly supported pro-Western leader who wanted peace with India.
After almost a decade in self-imposed exile, Bhutto's return to Pakistan in October gave her a fresh political start. Pakistan had changed, as military dictatorship and religious extremism in the north played havoc with the fabric of society. A tentative arrangement with Musharraf, together with Western support — particularly from the UK and the US — eased her return, which hundreds of thousands of people welcomed, though terrorists greeted her with a string of suicide bombings.
Bhutto's contacts with Musharraf's military government drew criticism, but she remained adamant that a return to democracy was possible only through a transition in which Musharraf would give up his military post, become a civilian head of state, and conduct free and fair elections.
To the dismay of some democratic forces, Bhutto stayed the course even after Musharraf imposed emergency rule on November 3 and removed the country's top judges to ensure his re-election. Indeed, she even persuaded other important political leaders to participate in the planned January 8 election, which she viewed as an opportunity to challenge religious extremist forces in the public square. She seized that opportunity by bravely travelling throughout the country, despite serious threats to her life, arguing for a democratic and pluralistic Pakistan.
One can understand why religious extremists such as al-Qa'ida and Taliban would target her, and the Government claims that it is impossible to defend against a suicide attack. But Bhutto was reportedly killed by a sharp shooter before the terrorist blew himself up. So in the eyes of Pakistan's people, and especially of Bhutto's supporters, the intelligence services, either alone or in collaboration with extremists, finally decided to eliminate her.
Whether or not the Government was involved, the fact remains that Pakistan has lost a desperately needed leader. With Pakistan's future in the balance, the West's help and support will be crucial, but that means recognising that Musharraf is not the only leader who can resolve Pakistan's many problems and manage the war on terror. On the contrary, by nurturing the present environment of instability and uncertainty, Musharraf himself must be regarded as one of Pakistan's biggest problems.
Hassan Abbas, who served in the administrations of Benazir Bhutto and Pervez Musharraf, is a research fellow at Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government and the author of Pakistan's Drift into Extremism: Allah, the Army and America's War on Terror.
For more information about this publication please contact the Belfer Center Communications Office at 617-495-9858.
Full text of this publication is available at:
For Academic Citation: