Belfer Center Home > Publications > Academic Papers & Reports > Working Papers > Beyond Optimism and Pessimism: The Differential Effects of Nuclear Proliferation

EmailEmail   PrintPrint Bookmark and Share

"Beyond Optimism and Pessimism: The Differential Effects of Nuclear Proliferation"

"Beyond Optimism and Pessimism: The Differential Effects of Nuclear Proliferation"

Working Paper 2009-14

November 2009

Author: Matthew Kroenig, Former Research Fellow, Project on Managing the Atom/International Security Program, 2007–2008

Belfer Center Programs or Projects: International Security; Managing the Atom; Science, Technology, and Public Policy



What is the effect of the spread of nuclear weapons on international politics?  The scholarly debate pits proliferation optimists, who claim that “more may be better,” against proliferation pessimists, who argue that “more will be worse.”  These scholars focus on the aggregate effects of nuclear proliferation, but never explicitly consider the differential effects of the spread of nuclear weapons.  In other words, they do not examine whether nuclear proliferation may threaten some states more than others.  I propose a theory of nuclear proliferation that examines the differential effects of nuclear proliferation.  I argue that the threat nuclear proliferation poses to a particular state depends on that state’s ability to project military power.  The spread of nuclear weapons is worse for states that have the ability to project conventional military power over a potential nuclear weapon state primarily because nuclear proliferation constrains their conventional military freedom of action.  On the other hand, nuclear proliferation is less threatening to, and can sometimes even improve the strategic environment of, states that lack the ability to project power over a potential nuclear weapon state, because the spread of nuclear weapons disproportionately constrains other, more powerful states.  This article contributes to our understanding of the consequences of nuclear proliferation and contains important implications for nuclear nonproliferation policy.




Click on the title below to download the paper.


For more information about this publication please contact the MTA Project Coordinator at 617-495-4219.

For Academic Citation:

Kroenig, Matthew. "Beyond Optimism and Pessimism: The Differential Effects of Nuclear Proliferation." Working Paper, November 2009.

Bookmark and Share


Receive email updates on the most pressing topics in science and int'l affairs.

<em>International Security</em>

The Fall 2014 Issue of the quarterly journal International Security
is now available!

See more research from Harvard Kennedy School faculty members by visiting the working paper series on the Kennedy School website.

Events Calendar

We host a busy schedule of events throughout the fall, winter and spring. Past guests include: UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, former Vice President Al Gore, and former Soviet Union President Mikhail Gorbachev.