Belfer Center Home > Publications > Academic Papers & Reports > Discussion Papers > The Promise and Problems of Pricing Carbon: Theory and Experience

EmailEmail   PrintPrint Bookmark and Share

 
The Promise and Problems of Pricing Carbon: Theory and Experience

Delegates listen to German Chancellor Angela Merkel respond to a question at the Petersberg Climate Dialogue in Berlin on July 3, 2011. The two-day dialogue was held in preparation for the upcoming UN climate conference in Durban.
AP Photo

The Promise and Problems of Pricing Carbon: Theory and Experience

Discussion Paper

November 2011

Authors: Joseph E. Aldy, Faculty Affiliate, Harvard Project on Climate Agreements, Robert N. Stavins, Albert Pratt Professor of Business and Government; Member of the Board; Director, Harvard Project on Climate Agreements

Belfer Center Discussion Papers

Belfer Center Programs or Projects: Environment and Natural Resources

 

In a modern economy, nearly all aspects of economic activity affect greenhouse gas – in particular, carbon dioxide (CO2) – emissions, and hence the global climate.  To be effective, climate change policy must affect decisions regarding these activities.  This can be done in one of three ways:  (1) mandate businesses and individuals to change their behavior regarding technology choice and emissions; (2) subsidize businesses and individuals to invest in and use lower-emitting goods and services; or (3) price the greenhouse gas externality, so that decisions take account of this external cost.

By internalizing the externalities associated with CO2 emissions, carbon pricing can promote cost-effective abatement, deliver powerful innovation incentives, and ameliorate rather than exacerbate government fiscal problems.  By pricing CO2 emissions (or, equivalently, by pricing the carbon content of the three fossil fuels – coal, petroleum, and natural gas), governments defer to private firms and individuals to find and exploit the lowest cost ways to reduce emissions and invest in the development of new technologies, processes, and ideas that could further mitigate emissions.  A range of policy instruments can facilitate carbon pricing, including carbon taxes, cap-and-trade, emission reduction credits, clean energy standards, and fossil fuel subsidy reduction. 

Some of these instruments have been used with success in other environmental domains, as well as for pricing CO2 emissions.  The U.S. sulfur dioxide (SO2) cap-and-trade program cut U.S. power plant SO2 emissions more than 50 percent after 1990, and resulted in compliance costs one half of what they would have been under conventional regulatory mandates (Carlson, Burtaw, Cropper, and Palmer, 2000).  The success of the SO2 allowance trading program motivated the design and implementation of the European Union’s Emission Trading Scheme (EU ETS), the world’s largest cap-and-trade program, focused on cutting CO2 emissions from power plants and large manufacturing facilities throughout Europe (Ellerman and Buchner, 2007).  The U.S. lead phase-down of gasoline in the 1980s, by reducing the lead content per gallon of fuel, served as an early, effective example of a tradable performance standard (Stavins, 2003).  These positive experiences provide motivation for considering market-based instruments as potential approaches to mitigating greenhouse gas emissions.

 

For more information about this publication please contact the ENRP Program Coordinator at 617-495-1351.

For Academic Citation:

Aldy, Joseph E. and Stavins, Robert N., “The Promise and Problems of Pricing Carbon: Theory and Experience,” Discussion Paper 2011-12, Cambridge, Mass.: Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, November 2011.

Bookmark and Share

"Policy for Energy Technology Innovation"
By Laura Diaz Anadon and John P. Holdren

"Acting in Time on Energy Policy"
By Kelly Sims Gallagher

Acting in Time on Energy Policy
By Kelly Sims Gallagher

SUBSCRIBE

Receive email updates on the most pressing topics in science and int'l affairs.

<em>International Security</em>

The winter 2013/14 issue of the quarterly journal International Security is now available!

Events Calendar

We host a busy schedule of events throughout the fall, winter and spring. Past guests include: UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, former Vice President Al Gore, and former Russian President Mikhail Gorbachev.